Lawyer Kanar: The aggravated life sentence regime must end

  • actual
  • 14:43 9 August 2021
  • |
img
İSTANBUL - Criminal lawyer Ercan Kanar stated that the 'aggravated life sentence' that was brought into the agenda when the ECtHR decision about Öcalan was brought before the European Council must end, and said: "Turkey violates the Mandela rules.'
 
Asrın Law Office consisting of the attorneys of PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan applied to European Court of Human Rights in 2003 on grounds that the isolation imposed on Öcalan in İmralı Type F Closed Prison violates the European Convention on Human Rights. ECtHR made a decision called 'Öcalan 2' on March 18, 2014 and ruled that life imprisonment without the possibility of parole şs a violation of Article 3 of the ECtHR.
 
The ECtHR rendered the same decision for the imprisoned Hayati Kaytan, Emin Gurban and Civan Boltan, who later applied. Despite the fact that 7 years have passed since the Öcalan decision, which was a predecessor for the applicants, no legal regulation was made that would give rise to the "right of hope" regarding aggravated life imprisonment without the possibility of release.
 
Despite the past 7 years, the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe did not take into account whether the ECHR decision was implemented or not. Association of Lawyers for Freedom (ÖHD), Human Rights Association (İHD), Human Rights Foundation of Turkey (TİHV) and Society and Legal Studies Foundation (TOHAV) applied to the European Council to take the violation decision about Öcalan on the urgent agenda.
 
BAR ASSOCIATIONS MUST APPLY
 
Underlining that an important and appropriate application was made despite being late, experienced criminal lawyer Ercan Kanar said that more institutions should participate in the application. Stating that the Union of Turkish Bar Associations (TBB) and local bar associations should participate in the application, Kanar said, "However, bar association administrations such as the Union of Bar Associations, Istanbul, Ankara and Izmir Bar Associations have not spoken out against such a discriminatory and racist execution regime so far."
 
RECOMMENDATIONS
 
Reminding the reccomendations of the European Council regarding the relevant governments years ago, Kanar said: ""In this recommendation, it is recommended to review the sentence periods between 8 and 14 years. In other words, there is a requirement to reconsider between 8 and 14 years in life imprisonment sentences. Therefore, when we look at it, this recommendation is more advanced than the decisions of the ECtHR. There is a 25-year recommendation in the ECHR decision."
 
SIMILAR ECtHR DECISIONS
 
Reminding the previous judgments of the ECtHR on Vinter and Others v. the United Kingdom, Kanar stated that the detainee's right to hope for freedom was implemented very clearly in this decision as well. Kanar said, “In the decision, it was underlined that the possibility of reviewing the sentence periods in certain periods should be included in the execution laws of the national states. Again, these issues were emphasized in the Kafkaris/Cyprus decision.”
 
LIFE HAS BECOME A PUNISHMENT
 
Emphasizing that every person has to have the right to be free one day, Kanar continued, "“Therefore, regardless of the act of the crime alleged to have been committed and the nature of the punishment given, the main purpose of the execution law is to ensure that the person is healed and to reintegrate them into society. Now, life imprisonment sentences do not have this property. As this situation turns into a death corridor, life has turned into a punishment. In other words, in addition to the punishment given, life itself has turned into punishment. Therefore, it is against human nature. It is both a discriminatory practice in terms of law and a racist practice in terms of politics.”
 
PATRIMONIAL REGIME
 
Saying that Norway abolished life imprisonment sentences in the 1880s, and then Portugal, Spain, Serbia and Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kanar said that the right to hope for freedom is a fundamental principle for every human being, according to the decisions of the German and Italian Constitutional Courts therefore life sentences should be reviewed periodically. Expressing that Turkey is not a state of law and therefore does not comply with the aforementioned decisions, Kanar said, “The AKP has eliminated all traces of law in the past 10 years. Turkey has turned into a patrimonial regime. What I mean by this is a corporate-type state with a dictatorial father at the head of it. It is the elimination of the legislative, executive, judicial separation and the gathering of all three powers in one hand. Therefore, the decisions of the ECtHR are not followed.”
 
THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE
 
Reminding that the Committee of Council of Europe  is responsible to enforce the ECtHR decisions, Kanar said that the committee should act boldly and warn Turkey. Saying that if the warning is not followed, the decision should be taken to the Grand Chamber of the ECtHR, Kanar said, “When the decision is made by the Grand Chamber, it should be sanctioned. What sanctions could there be? The right to vote at the Council of Europe can be taken away from Turkey. A further solution could remove Turkey from the council membership. Unfortunately, the political conjuncture does not seem appropriate for such sanctions. Europe is going through a weak period. Therefore, it does not even implement its own decision. Economic and political decisions prevent the implementation of such sanctions."
 
MANDELA RULES 
 
Reminding that the United Nations (UN) introduced mandatory rules to be applied for prisoners, Kanar said these rules were revised in 2005. Underlining that these rules called the Mandela Rules are being violated by Turkey, Kanar continued, "According to these rules, there should never be a long-term solitary confinement sentence. Even in the most severe disciplinary punishments, family visits should not be prohibited. Regardless, the prisoner should be kept in a prison close to where his family is. Again, his communication and lawyer visits should not be provided. All non-prohibited publications should be available without censorship. The prisoner must also be given a copy of the records kept about him in the prison. But Turkey is disregarding the Mandela rules.”
 
'LIFE IMPRISONMENT MUST BE ABOLISHED' 
 
Stating that political parties must be pressured in order for the implementation of these rules, Kanar said: "The main opposition claiming to be social democrats ignores this issue completely. They cover up the discriminatory and racist practices in the prison system. Ofcourse it does not make any sense to expect this from İYİ Party. However the parties that claim to be social democrats must stand against these violations. For example, the Workers' Party of Turkey (TIP) needs to have a more firm stance against these violations. HDP alone will not be able to do it on its own. Life imprisonment should now be removed from the penal code. Penal legislation should get rid of such inhuman, discriminatory and degrading forms of punishment. Just as we once called the death penalty a "bankrupt punishment method", now life imprisonment is an outdated punishment. Human rights institutions and legal institutions need to campaign for this penalty to be removed from the legislation.”
 
MA / Ferhat Çelik

View More Articles

21/07/2022
10:14 Sadiqun Group: Turkey's Zaxo attack is a declaration of war on Iraq
20/07/2022
19:02 The 16 Kurdish journalists win the Turkish Journalists’ Freedom of Press Award
16:49 Petition for Aydeniz, whose immunity to be lifted
16:12 SDF's Commander-in-Chief receives Lieutenant General Michael Corella
15:50 Turkish attack against civilians results in casualties in Zakho countryside
15:36 Attack on Kurdish family in Denizli
14:27 Şenyaşar family: We commemorate 33 dream travelers with respect
13:33 Investigation launched against JINNEWS reporter Değer
12:43 Mother longing for justice at her murdered son's grave for 7 years
19/07/2022
18:16 Turkish court upholds exit from treaty protecting women
13:20 Mazlum Ebdi: We will turn July 19 into a kick off of a new move
12:45 Lawsuit against Öcalan's attorneys postponed
12:45 Lawyers of Öcalan submits new application for a visit in İmralı
12:01 Prisoners in Kürkçüler Prison on hunger strike
11:41 Journalist Seyda: The cause of the crisis in Iraq is the KDP
18/07/2022
18:11 Onur Gencer, the murderer of Deniz Poyraz, avoided the questions
15:13 Survivors of Suruç Massacre: They tried to destroy our will
14:18 Emine Şenyaşar: Release my son
13:43 Battered prisoner: Guards will kill me
10:44 Gunman tried to enter courthouse with pump rifle in Deniz Poyraz hearing
16/07/2022
12:52 Gravestone of Kurdish young man died in Sur, destroyed a second time
12:45 Şenyaşar family: Sermonasing will not bring peace and prosperity
12:45 16 journalists behind bars for a month
15/07/2022
15:59 Quarterly balance sheet of Turkish attacks
15:57 Ferit Şenyaşar: We will keep saying rights, law, justice
15:56 Greenpeace: Cutting trees in the region is out of our area of expertise
15:08 KDP forces played Turkish music while driving journalist Geerdink to airport for deportation
13:32 Call from Kakabaveh: Ask Sweden about the 4 people they extradited to Turkey
12:25 Suspicious death in prison: They made it look like suicide
14/07/2022
16:32 ATK said for the third time that Tuğluk could 'be held in prison'
15:04 Şenyaşar family will continue the justice watch in front of Elazig Prison today
14:59 Letters of imprisoned journalists confiscated
14:55 Families of imprisoned journalists subjected to strip search
13:55 Racist attacks increased, refugees apply to the association
13/07/2022
16:35 Şenyaşar family: Those who remain silent to the cries of justice will lose
15:59 'Öcalan became the foundation of Kurdistan, and those who lost their lives in death fast became its pillars
13:24 Sarısözen: They will betrap Turkey with the Syrian attack
10/07/2022
14:45 Şenyaşar Family's Justice Watch on day 489
14:31 Solidarity message from imprisoned female journalists
13:47 Eyüp Barzani: The regional economy is under the control of Turkey
13:05 ÖHD attorneys: Law has turned into a black hole in İmralı
09/07/2022
15:48 Emine Şenyaşar in front of the courthouse: This place has become my home
14:41 Kurdo Baksi: Madrid Summit failed
10:48 Ertaş's letter was confiscated on the grounds that he 'continues to work as a journalist'
08/07/2022
16:42 Journalist Özdemir: There are footages of dozens of soldiers who lost their lives
16:22 90's back again: Enterences to villages banned, food embargo
12:26 Clashes intensified in rural areas of Southeastern Kurdish city Van
12:15 Bodies of dozens of soldiers taken to hospitals in Hakkari
11:45 Journalists subjected to police violence: Everyone should come together
07/07/2022
15:48 Senyaşar family's sit-in is on the 486th day