'Witness' police in Gezi trial: They were carrying a lot of lemons

  • actual
  • 13:14 24 December 2019
  • |
img

İSTANBUL - The fourth hearing of Gezi trial has started today, in the wake of an ECtHR verdict of right violation given for Anadolu Kültür Executive Board Chair Osman Kavala, the only arrested defendant of the case.

The fourth hearing of the lawsuit filed into the Gezi Park protests continue at the İstanbul 30th Heavy Penal Court in Silivri Prison Campus today and tomorrow (December 24-25).
 
16 people including Anadolu Kültür Executive Board Chair Osman Kavala, the only arrested defendant of the case, are facing aggravated life sentence on charge of "attempting to overthrow the government" for allegedly having organized the Gezi Park protests in 2013.
 
Kavala is also accused of "funding the protests".
In the fourth hearing of the case to be held today and tomorrow, the people alleging that they came to harm due to Gezi protests are also heard.
 
Referring to the verdict of right violation given by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) on December 10, the attorneys of Kavala have requested the release of the arrested businessperson and rights defender.
 
Today's hearing started with the Presiding Judge's remarks on his decision to remove courtroom artists Tarık Tolunay and Murat Başol from the court in the previous hearing. The Judge said, "We did say that it was prohibited to make courtroom illustrations, but we did not have anyone removed from the courtroom. They said they were removed but that is not true."
 
After the hearing started, the defendants took the floor. Speaking first in the hearing, witness Ercan Orhan Aydın, the Chief of Security Branch, said that they were "were assigned to various positions, at streets leading to Taksim, Talimhane and the German Hospital" and added that "the protesters were throwing them burning things with a catapult system."
 
When the Presiding Judge asked "what they knew about the defendants", witness Aydın stated the following in brief: "They showed me their photographs, I indicated the ones I knew. We followed orders.
 
"I know about how the Gezi Park events began from the press. The trees were to be cut down, then groups arrived. As the security branch and the riot squad we followed orders. In terms of ideology, it was complex.
 
"There were no negotiations. I did make announcements for them to disperse. I may have seen them in detention. But I can't say that any one of them carried out a violent act."
 
The Presiding Judge also asked the witness, "Did any defendant in our case file hold a press statement or meeting to expand these actions? Were you witness to any statement by them to attack or resist the police intervention?"
 
Ercan Orhan Aydın answered this question as follows: "There were police vehicles on the steps of Gezi Park. We made announcements, but they didn't disperse. That shows that the action has crossed the line. But it was everywhere. Everyone was making detentions, not only our team.
 
"Protestors were firmly organized. For instance, we would intervene in a group of 20 wearing masks at Mis Sokak, then a short time later the same group would reappear in Galatasaray. They dispersed, but gathered again.
 
"Where does Osman Kavala stand in all this... What did he do in the background... I wish I knew. The protestors were organizing so easily."
 
to the question of the Presiding Judge, "Which defendant was among the organizers, who was there?", the witness answered, "There was Twitter. I didn't use social media then, I still don't. We followed things on WhatsApp. We have a social media desk, they kept track of calls to action."
 
Osman Kavala's lawyer İlkan Koyuncu asked the witness, "Did you see Osman Kavala organizing these events?", to which he answered, "It was here in the courtroom that I saw Osman Kavala for the first time."
 
When Koyuncu further asked, "Did you see Osman Kavala involved in violence against police?", the witness again answered, "No, I didn't."
 
Directing a question to the witness, lawyer Bahri Belen asked, "Mr. Ercan you mentioned certain press statements. Did you see anyone at these press statements who provoked the crowd to carry out action against the police?" The witness answered, "No, I didn't. Those who did this weren't the people holding statements, they hid at the back."
 
Afterwards, witness Hasan Gül from the İstanbul Security Branch was called to the witness stand. When he was asked, "Do you have any knowledge about which defendants took part in attacks on the police or public property or the organization of this?", he answered as follows:
 
"The unit I work at does not have access to such information. We were assigned to follow actions in view of info gathered from social media.
 
"Security branch follows visible social events, and calls on the riot squad if it observes criminal activity. It seeks to end such events without a problem. It negotiates. I know about the defendants only in the context of indictment.
 
"I know Osman Kavala's name not from actions, but from general knowledge. I have worked at the security branch for many years and I am aware of his involvement in NGOs. I don't know where he was during Gezi. I have definitely not seen him involved in any violent action."
 
"I negotiated with Can Atalay both during Gezi and after. One of the most crowded funerals was Berkin Elvan's funeral. I can say that he was determined in his stance to follow our negotiations then, to end events without a problem. That was very important during that period."
 
When Osman Kavala's lawyer, İlkan Koyuncu asked, "You said you witnessed individuals carrying out violent acts. Was Osman Kavala one of them?", witness Gül answered, "No."
 
After the witness statements were heard, the defendants responded to their statements. Osman Kavala said, "The witnesses have provided no information indicating that I took part in any act of violence, that I provoked any such act, or that I was a director of the Gezi Events."
 
Mücella Yapıcı also stated, "The press statements we made were about our most basic rights. I was already acquitted on those. But I couldn't help feel that the witnesses had been oriented. Nevertheless their statements show that the indictment is groundless."
 
Çiğdem Mater Utku also said, "As far as I can understand, the issue does not have anything to do with us."
 

View More Articles

06/10/2020
13:56 Yeni Yaşam Newspaper distributer Erdem detained in Van
13:55 Hundreds of people express solidarity with HDP MP Garo Paylan
13:55 Lawyer restriction on journalists detained in Van
11:40 Journalisism organizations protests detentions of MA and Jinnews reporters
11:39 Home raids in multiple cities: Peace mothers being detained
11:39 Journalist exposing the villagers thrown from helicopter detained
11:38 Kobané protests: Impunity makes it harder for us to handle the deaths
08:11 Police raid on our Van Bureau: 4 journalists detained
02/10/2020
16:55 6 months lawyer ban for Öcalan
16:53 MPs commented on the trustee: The people will hold you to account
16:52 Police raid on HDP building in Aydın
13:45 Journalist Boltan and 13 people referred to court
13:03 Governor prays in front of the city hall where he was appointed as a trustee
13:02 Police attacks people protesting the trustee in Kars
11:56 Brother of Pınar Gültekin's brother arrested
11:56 Families submit application to visit İmralı
10:46 Trustee appointed to Kars municipality
10:45 Kobané investigation: 17 HDP members arrested, including Kars Mayor Ayhan Bilgen
10:44 Summaries against 23 lawyers opposing multiple bar associations
10:44 Media blackout decision for the investigation on two men thrown out of a helicopter
01/10/2020
16:56 36 women were murdered in September
15:27 CHP visits HDP's sit in action
15:26 HDP starts sit in at the parliament
12:31 Lawyers of Öcalan submit new application for a visit
12:31 Police raids Servet Turgut's wake
11:38 HDP Politicians under custody, brought to courthouse
11:30 Özcan: USA wants a structure that minimizes Turkey's concerns
10:29 Number of people detained increase in the Mardin based operation
10:29 Operation against HDP in Kars: Co-Mayor Alaca detained
09:14 Servet Turgut's brother: End this cruelty
30/09/2020
17:05 Armenia is considering formally recognizing Artsakh / Karabakh independence
17:05 Number of people detained in Diyarbakır rises to 14
13:56 Warrant of arrest issued for journalist Akman
13:56 Journalists and writers call for support for HDP
13:06 791 women demanded the politicians of HDP to be released
13:06 Ayhan Bilgen announced his resignation under police custody
13:05 Yeneroğlu: If Turkey was ruled by law, the Minister of Interior would be held to account
11:17 Journalist Berekat: Crimes against humanity are committed in Efrîn, Girê Spî and Serêkanîyê
09:50 Servet Turgut thrown out of a helicopter, lost his life
09:44 Danzikyan: Turkey headed towards Armenia when its plans failed in Libya and Syria
09:24 Journalist Hakkı Boltan detained
09:23 No rocks in the area where Turgut was detained!
29/09/2020
16:46 Interrogation of the politicians under custody starts
16:06 Constitutional Court postpones reviewing Osman Kavala’s application
16:05 Enterances of Kars closed to HDP
14:11 Lawyers of Öcalan submit new application for a visit
14:10 Sever: Turkey aims to establish a military base in Azerbaijan
14:09 Court upholds that the 'Kobané investigation' is repeated
11:09 HDP Mersin Co-chair and PM member detained
11:08 Investigation against ‘Movement of the Nameless’: 3 people arrested