Why does the Committee enforced ECHR ruling on Azerbaijan avoid acting against Turkey?

  • actual
  • 09:23 17 October 2025
  • |
img

NEWS CENTER – The Council of Europe’s Committee of Ministers, which ensured Azerbaijan implemented a ECHR ruling, has failed to take similar steps against Turkey, despite Ankara’s 11-year refusal to recognize the “right to hope.” PACE member Berdan Öztürk said the recent dissolution of the PKK removes all of Turkey’s justifications for inaction: “They have no excuse left.”

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled in March 2014 that Kurdish People’s Leader Abdullah Öcalan’s “right to hope” had been violated, finding that life sentences without parole breach Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits inhuman or degrading treatment. Similar rulings followed for political prisoners Hayati Kaytan, Emin Gurban, and Civan Boltan.
 
Despite these rulings, Turkey has taken no steps to comply. The Committee of Ministers, responsible for overseeing the implementation of ECHR judgements, reviewed the case several times, first in 2015, then in 2021, and repeatedly urged Turkey to make legislative reforms. The Committee most recently discussed the “Gurban Group” cases in September 2025, granting Turkey yet another deadline until June 2026, while warning that failure to act could result in interim measures. 
 
However, critics argue that the Committee’s leniency reflects political double standards, especially when compared to its firm stance toward Azerbaijan in the Ilgar Mammadov case.
 
THE CASE OF ILGAR MAMMADOV
 
 
In 2014, the ECHR ruled that the imprisonment of Azerbaijani opposition leader Ilgar Mammadov was politically motivated and violated his right to liberty. After years of non-compliance, the Committee of Ministers initiated an “infringement procedure” — the first of its kind — forcing Baku to act. Mammadov was conditionally released in 2018 and fully cleared in 2020. When Azerbaijan continued to violate other human rights obligations, its PACE delegation was suspended in 2024.
 
‘TURKEY COULD FACE THE SAME MEASURES’
 
Co-spokesperson for Foreign Relations of the Peoples' Equality and Democracy (DEM) Party and Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) member Berdan Öztürk, who raised the “right to hope” issue during the Council’s last plenary session, said the Committee president avoided addressing Öcalan’s situation directly. He said: “I reminded them that the Council was founded on three principles, democracy, the rule of law, and human rights. I asked how they could justify ignoring a ruling that’s been pending for 11 years. The response was evasive. They spoke in generalities but avoided the real issue.”
 
 
Comparing Turkey’s case with Azerbaijan’s, Öztürk argued: “They could easily apply the same sanctions to Turkey, even suspend its membership if necessary. But they choose not to, because of Turkey’s economic and political ties with Europe and its strategic role in NATO.”
 
‘MUTUAL INTERESTS AND DOUBLE STANDARDS’
 
Öztürk said the Committee’s reluctance undermines its credibility: “Their unwillingness to act turns the Council into an institution of double standards. Turkey remains under ‘monitoring,’ yet no effective measure is taken. If the 2014 ruling had been implemented, many political prisoners, including Demirtaş, Yüksekdağ, and Kavala, might not be in prison today.”
 
He added that the Committee’s approach reflects “mutual interests” rather than principles: “They don’t want to upset Turkey but also can’t deny the violations, so they try to find a middle ground. But this weakens the Council’s moral and legal authority.”
 
‘NO EXCUSE LEFT AFTER PKK’S DISSOLUTION’
 
Linking the issue to the ongoing Peace and Democratic Society Process, Öztürk said: “At first, some Council members thought the AKP government had an agreement with the PKK. We explained that it was actually the state acting, and that Öcalan’s influence is undeniable, as seen in the PKK’s decision to dissolve and burn its weapons. This is a historic moment.”
 
He concluded: “Until now, Turkey used the PKK’s existence as an excuse not to act. That excuse no longer exists. The Council now bears full responsibility for ensuring Öcalan’s ‘right to hope’ and physical freedom. If they truly care about democracy and human rights, they must act. We will keep this issue on the international agenda.”
 
MA / Diren Yurtsever

View More Articles

12:38 Abdullah Ocalan: The right to hope is a step that the state must take
11:56 While 'solution' being discussed, the government building 'security roads'
10:26 Doctor who joined Rojin Kabais’s autopsy: Deficiencies in the investigation have complicated the process
09:23 Why does the Committee enforced ECHR ruling on Azerbaijan avoid acting against Turkey?
15/10/2025
13:47 Ahmet Türk: The state must act in line with the spirit of the process”
13:13 Journalist Aykol taken into surgery again
11:45 The plan to move Tehran without water: The regime is the cause of the crisis
10:48 Youth prepare for marches in two cities: Let’s rise together for freedom
09:25 Property disputes persist in Cyprus following Turkish occupation
14/10/2025
16:58 One thousand 800 letters from women to Abdullah Öcalan
13:38 Right to treatment of Zeinab Jalalian being denied
12:11 ‘Kurdish people’s demand is freedom of Abdullah Öcalan’
11:29 Trump’s Assignment to Erdogan: End Hamas
09:46 15 people arrested in Bursa
09:37 Journalist Hakan Tosun's brain death occurred
13/10/2025
12:41 Women's and youth to be heard in the Parliamen's commission
12:37 Peter McLaren: Öcalan’s words crossed the waters like a dove
12:27 Asrin Law Office lawyers go to İmralı
09:02 11 years since the killing of Kadri Bağdu: The case must be reopened
08:12 2 arrest in connection with attack on journalist Tosun
12/10/2025
15:25 Abdullah Ocalan poster in Êlih rally
15:07 ‘Conference of Peoples and Faiths’ issues final declaration
13:47 Journalist Tosun found beaten on the roadside
13:31 Pastor Peker: Without legal reforms, the peace process will remain symbolic
11:33 Rojin Kabaiş Investigation: Prosecutor must open a sexual assault case
10:13 Abdullah Ocalan offers formula for humanity’s coexistence says jounalist Estukyan
08:47 Culture and Art Festival started in Nisêbîn
10/10/2025
17:08 Legal institutions call for official status for the Kurdish
15:29 Taşdemir welcomed in his hometown after 32 years
13:42 What do writers and artists say about the process?
12:50 Police attack on Gar Massacre commemoration
12:45 104 victims remembered where they killed: The call for peace from 10 years ago still resounds
12:00 Day Against the Death Penalty: Executions are on the rise in Iran
09:56 ‘Prisoners cannot go to hospital for 3 years due to oral search’
09:54 ÖHD Co-Chair: Listening to Öcalan is a historic responsibility
09:52 Women organize ‘to live and let live’
09/10/2025
19:59 Transitional government shelled area around Tishreen announced SDF
19:50 Conspiracy March in Amed: We will continue struggle until Öcalan is free
17:07 Barzani-Erdoğan meeting starts
17:03 Commission in the Parliament to go to Amed
16:34 Nechirvan Barzani meet with Foreing Minister of Turkey
16:27 SDF statement on attacks of interim government
16:26 Conspiracy protests: Freedom of Ocalan will be most concrete step for peace
14:07 She waits to return to Afrin after 31 years
14:04 'Women to take to streets for Abdullah Öcalan's physical freedom'
12:58 Peace Mothers witnessing conspiracy: It was a black day
10:40 Tree slaughter continues in Dorşîn
10:31 The conspiracy not over, Leader Apo still a hostage says Salih Muslim
09:09 Erden releases after 30 years in prison
08:37 Abdullah Ocalan: Gurbetelli's memory is a guiding legacy for all of us